Inaccuracies in the movie 300

Rise of an empire movie is the battle of marathon in 490 bc. Despite the awesomeness that is the 300 film and the sequel the epic battles, the amazing directing, the incredible cinematography by zack snyder, and all the impressive special effects our mission in this site is very specific, and thus, this article focuses on the historical inaccuracies of this movie. Perhaps the movie 300 was a necessary wakeup call for the iranianpersian community to support responsible filmmakers, who report history with honesty and integrity. Does the movie 300 accurately portray the fighting style of. After youve finished reading our analysis of the 300. Almost the complete movie is historically inaccurate. Historical accuracies in the snyders film introduction herodotus and zac snyder have at least one thing in common. Check out our top free essays on historical accuracies and inaccuracies of movie 300 to help you write your own essay. Task ephialtes the part of the film i have chosen to compare with the graphic novel is when ephialtes approaches leonidas with the knowledge of a secret pass that the persians could use to counterattack the spartans. Although in real life the spartan government was a military oligarchy with a mix of monarchy and democracy.

Analysis of the movie 300 by frank miller and lynn varley 925 words 4 pages. Historic accuracy of the movie 300 essay example topics. The historical accuracies of 300 historian on the warpath. In the movie the spartans are ruled in a monarchy ruled by the one king leonidas. The movie 300 has the spartan soldiers fighting nearly naked without any form of body armor protecting them. He said, the inaccuracies, almost all of them, are intentional. An analysis of the historical inaccuracies in the movie. Apr 09, 2018 unlike the movie title suggests, the spartan warrior leonidas had well over 300 people assist in the war against the persians. First of all, the battle of thermopylae happened nearly 2,500 years ago. That being said, the 300 spartan soldiers achievement did happen pretty much as its portrayed in zack snyders movie.

Thats fine, since most of us know that a fictional movie is not a documentary. It primarily focuses on the battle of thermopylae, a very. Posted on february 24, 2016 february 24, 2016 by rollyn stafford. The movie would have you believe noble sparta was the sole defense for freedom. Historical accuracies in the snyders film 300 1593. I didnt want to render sparta in overly accurate terms, because ultimately i do. Its strong opening is a clear indicator of its success with the. When i first saw it i thought as im sure most people do that it was completely ridiculous how they portrayed thermopylae, but whilst reading herodotus histories, i saw that he describes how the spartans threw two persian diplomats into a well. Rise of an empire movie has so many historical flaws. Mar 17, 2014 despite the awesomeness that is the 300 film and the sequel the epic battles, the amazing directing, the incredible cinematography by zack snyder, and all the impressive special effects our mission in this site is very specific, and thus, this article focuses on the historical inaccuracies of this movie. Free essays on historical accuracies and inaccuracies of movie 300. This prequelsequelsamequel is just as full of slowmotion as you expect, and just as devoid of actual story as well.

Separating fact from fiction grossing over 70 million dollars in its first week of release, the movie 300 is set to crash into the list of highest grossing hollywood blockbusters. But alex jovys movie today sits idle due lack of money. The movie 300 is about king leonidas of sparta and a force of 300 men fighting against the persians at thermopylae in 480 b. In its essence, 300 is a retelling of herodotos account of the battle of thermopylai 480 bc, meaning that its basic narrative is as historically accurate as we could hope for. It shows nothing of how the spartan culture was built on the backs of slaves throughout their economy, society, and military ironic, as leonidas talks about fighting for greek freedom. In its essence, 300 is a retelling of herodotos account of the battle of thermopylae 480 bc, meaning that its basic narrative is as historically accurate as we could hope for. Technical errors and inaccuracies in the movie 300.

Oct 15, 2009 the movie 300 was different to real life sparta in the fact of how the government was run. An analysis of the historical inaccuracies in the movie 300. The 10 most historically inaccurate movies of all time the 10 most historically inaccurate movies of all time. The grim, ghastly, almost monstrously barbaric yet weirdly effeminate features of the persian leader xerxes is. In all honesty, any movie about history is not going to be completely accurate. Ephraim lytle, assistant professor of hellenistic history at the university of. Sparta, spandex and disturbing distortions of 300 live. If one looks hard enough, they are bound to find something the directorscreenwriter. Getting all the facts correct about the battle is impossible. Body armor was a valuable asset to the real spartan soldiers. Free essays on historical accuracies and inaccuracies of. The battle of thermopylae was a battle between the persians, spartans, and their allies that took place at the pass of thermopylae or hot gates. Out of the 1,523 cuts featured in 300, more than 1,300 of its shots contain some elements of visual effects. Its strong opening is a clear indicator of its success with the north american and by implication, european audiences.

Adam ruins everything the 300 spartans and their 6,700. As natalia correctly points out, the most accurate account we have is from herodotus. January 8 th 2012 katie keyes comp civ 21 300 inaccuracies assignment the movie 300 is based on a graphic novel, which itself claims to be loosely based on the historical fact of the battle of thermopylae, where the outnumbered greek army fought the massive persian army. Whem a sword slashes or a spear lungs or an arrow whistles, you really feel and hear it. Overall the movie does a decent job showing one interpretation of a possible conflict that we simply dont know much about. Technical errors and inaccuracies in the movie 300 the game. Below i have stated 23 major historical errors in this movie and i can keep on going on and on but time does not allow me to do so. In the movie 300 we are discussing today, the creator frank miller was up front about it. The 10 most historically inaccurate movies of all time. On the contrary, its very easy to believe how inaccurate this is. Essay example, 1590 words gradesfixer 300 is a movie directed by zack snyder and based on true events that took place in the b.

Despite the awesomeness that is the 300 film and the sequel the epic. When the blood hits the the ground it suddenly disappears. The movie plays up the machismo aspect because it is. Does the movie 300 accurately portray the fighting style. Historical accuracy of the film 300 the zack synder directed film 300 may have been a box office blockbuster, but it is aligned very little to history and riddled with a.

Oct 09, 2008 300 in the film, a deformed spartan called ephialtes is tempted over to the persian side when xerxes shows him a tent full of naked ladies who just cant get enough of really ugly men. Rise of an empire is a prequel, a sidesequel, and a sequel to the original film, 300 2007, with the events in the followup taking place before, during, and after the events in the original. Jun 19, 2019 many people learned about the glorious last stand of the 300 spartans at thermopylae in history class, but few had any reason to remember much about it or think much of it until the movie 300 hit the big screen. Ive had the same concern about movies like flyboys, but not about 300 first of all, the battle. In its essence, 300 is a retelling of herodotos account of the battle of thermopylai 480 bc, meaning that its basic narrative is as historically accurate as we. There are countless other inaccuracies and plenty of funny mistakes to be found, like the greek army extra who takes a tumble as the army charges for the first big battle. This movie was based on the battle of thermopylae which took. About as historically accurate as the tale of christopher columbus setting off on a voyage to prove the world was round. May 26, 2016 so one of our readers asked us this question the other day. This information is more or less where the accuracy ends and the fallacies of the movie begin. The film gained worldwide recoginition, has won five academy awards including best picture and best director, and was nominated for another five. The battle of thermopylae was real, but how real is the movie 300.

Truth and hollywood fiction at times of greco persian wars. The movie 300 was a great movie about the battle of thermopylae. Mar 25, 2007 to me 300 is an absolutely terrific movie. Persians under the rule of king xerxes have already taken over some of the hellenic citystates, and now threaten sparta and athens. Hopefully this video will give you the bullet points please like comment and subscribe for new videos and let us know. Probably about as embellished too depending on the source. In reality xerxes was a dignified man, a big beard, long thick hair. Discuss this article in the forums with the big success of 300, there have been some purists who have expressed concerns that the movie is doing an injustice to history. Ive had the same concern about movies like flyboys, but not about 300. Feb 16, 2016 300 was a big flashy and overly stylized action movie, but how accurate is it. Mar 04, 2014 five reasons 300 is historically bullsht. I wanted these guys to move and i wanted em to look good. The movie 300 was different to real life sparta in the fact of how the government was run.

However, there are at least 3 layers of historical inaccuracy piled on top of that, which makes the result ever so slightly less reliable. The 10 most historically inaccurate movies of all time posted on february 24, 2016 february 24, 2016 by rollyn stafford in all honesty, any movie about history is not going to be completely accurate. An analysis of the historical inaccuracies in the movie 300 by zack. The personal guard of the king of sparta, alongside 7. It primarily focuses on the battle of thermopylae, a very important battle during the grecopersian war which took place during the second persian invasion of greece. First, there are no completely accurate eyewitness accounts of thermopylae. Mar 04, 2016 thats fine, since most of us know that a fictional movie is not a documentary. Gordan, is very, very loosely based on the story of the three hundred spartans who fought and died in the battle of thermopylai in 480 b. At the end of the day, what makes the movie are the thrilling fight sequences with encounters in which the film is slowed down and then speeded up to give a videogame quality that is unlike anything you have previously seen on the big screen. With the big success of 300, there have been some purists who have expressed concerns that the movie is doing an injustice to history.

One goof in all movies is that there were several hundred other greeks from other cities that died at thermopylae, more than the 300 spartans themselves. Just before astinos death, immediately after his father calls to him saying astinos, my son, throughout the following shot of astinos, the horse and rider can be seen in the dust, midway between the illfated young man and the righthand side of the screen, stationary and waiting for his cue. This is just one of many historical inaccuracies found in 300, a movie that hardly goes out of its way to be realistic. This worksheet has students explore those inaccuracies during and after viewing. Scarlet red robes and a nice yellow big screen combined with rolling base and excellent narration sparked peoples imaginations and. Leonidas chooses to believe and trust ephialtes, despite his. Some of them were necessary, but some were really disappointing. Many people learned about the glorious last stand of the 300 spartans at thermopylae in history class, but few had any reason to remember much about it or think much of it until the movie 300 hit the big screen.

Historical accuracies in the snyders film 300 1593 words. The movie 300 has the spartan soldiers fighting nearly naked without any form. May 25, 20 an examination of historical inaccuracies in the feature film 300 the movie, 300 by zack snyder, based on the graphic novel of the same name by frank miller, tells one of the most epic tales in human history. Xerxes the great persian emperor, 300 rise of an empire 2014. The 2006 fantasy action film 300, directed by zack snyder and written by snyder, kurt johnstad, and michael b. Im doing an essay about the historical inaccuracies about the film 300. Despite the awesomeness that is the 300 film and the sequel the epic battles, the amazing directing, the incredible cinematography by zack snyder, and all the impressive special effects our mission in this site is very specific, and thus, this article. In the first major battle between the 300 spartans and the persians, leonidas is slaughtering the persians and the speed of the scene goes from slow motion to fast motion, you see very realistic cgi blood. In december 2007, 300 won igns movie of the year 2007, along with best comic book adaptation and king leonidas as favorite character.

Technical errors and inaccuracies in the movie 300 the game of. Historical inaccuracies in the movie braveheart free. An analysis of the historical inaccuracies in the movie 300 by zack snyder. Far more than just the 300 spartans showed up at thermopylae. Technical errors and inaccuracies in the movie 300 the. It also sparked the interest of many in scottish history. I d essay historical accuracies inaccuracies film 300.

The most historically inaccurate movies ever readers digest. The historical inaccuracies in 300 today i found out. Alex jovys epic movie about cyrus the great could have done wonders for the iranian image. The movie barveheart in 1995, which was starred, produced and directed by academy award winner mel gibson, depicted or tried to depict the life of scottish hero and patriot sir william wallace. He said, the inaccuracies, almost all of them, are. Historical inaccuracies in the movie the 300 spartans. This happens many times during this long and awesome scene.